Wednesday, March 11, 2020

NO GOOD DEED GOES UNPUNISHED


As a parent, I find myself often telling my children that their benevolence will reap rewards.  When they act in caring and helpful ways, especially for those in need, they will feel good about themselves and others will appreciate it.[1]  Sadly, the phrase “No good deed goes unpunished” has become a cynical twist on this idea, meaning, sometimes good intentions and acts of kindness aren’t properly appreciated or, may mean, doing something kind will lead to expectations and demands for more help and benefits the recipient believes they deserve.[2]

The good deed Jeremiah has in mind is his prophetic ministry of bringing God’s word to the people.  He mentions specifically speaking to God on the people’s behalf and turning God’s wrath away from them.  In turn for his good deed, Jeremiah’s enemies feel free to remove him because this will not result in the loss of anything essential.  So, they plan to listen carefully to what Jeremiah says in order to use his words against him.[3]

Today’s Gospel is also a shocker for modern readers and listeners—or, sadly maybe it’s not.  Jesus declares to his closest, most loyal followers the third prediction of the things he will endure in Jerusalem.  He, “the Son of Man,” will be arrested.  Response from disciples: nothing.  He will be handed over to be mocked and scourged.  Response: nothing.  He will be put to death.  Response: nothing.  He will rise from the dead on the third day.  Response: Jesus, when all of this happens, “Command that these two sons of mine sit, one at your right and the other at your left, in your kingdom.” (Mt 20:21) On one hand this displays commendable faith; yet on the other hand, it shows a failure to understand the implications of establishing a kingdom through suffering, death, and resurrection.

What is most interesting in this telling: We hear no concern or empathy for Jesus good deed, the suffering he will soon face.  Rather, it’s as if the only response is, “Now what’s in it for me?”

What a dramatic way for Jesus to tell his followers—and us—this important message!  That our lives are to be lived for others.  It’s not about our own authority, reputation, or reward instead, it is about serving God and neighbor.  We are only five chapters away from the great “final judgment” scene where God’s ultimate question is not, “What did you do in your life to obtain success, power, and reputation?” but rather, “What did you do for others, especially the unsuccessful people, the powerless people, the people whose reputation is poor—or even worse, nonexistent?”[4]


[1] Huffpost, “No Good Deed Goes Unpunished” by Rabbi Jason Miller. Posted: May 13, 2016.
[2] Grammarist. “No good deed goes unpunished”
[3] Weekday HomilyHelps. Exegesis by Dr. Terrance Callan.
[4] Ibid. Homily Suggestion by Linus Mundy.

No comments:

Post a Comment